I’ve been thinking lately about organizational culture, culture change, and what it takes to give feedback that’s both constructive and authentic. Part of that was timing: I left one agency for another, and the two cultures aren’t alike at all. I love the work my predecessor and my new org have already put in, and one thread runs through most of it: the same tension between honesty and empathy.

That org is built around four core tenets: Listening, Ownership, Growth, and Stewardship. Achieving this vision requires redefining what “high performance” means: not grinding people harder, but growing them, building competency, helping people work smarter instead of just longer. One conversation keeps resurfacing: growth doesn’t depend on effort alone, and it doesn’t depend on honesty alone either. It takes leaders willing to name the truth, and leaders willing to support people through it, both at once, not as a trade-off.

I’ve written before about receiving feedback: how to tell the useful kind from the kind that’s just noise. This is the other side of it: giving that feedback. Most of what makes a leader worth following comes down to doing both halves, honesty and empathy, at once.

Both Things Are True

Plenty of leadership advice treats honesty and empathy like opposite ends of a dial: turn one up, the other comes down. Be the blunt, no-nonsense leader who “tells it like it is,” or be the warm, supportive one who protects people’s feelings. Pick a lane.

I don’t buy it. Kim Scott’s Radical Candor gets closest to the actual shape of the problem: two separate axes, not one dial. Care Personally on one, Challenge Directly on the other. Drop the challenge and keep only the care, and you get what she calls Ruinous Empathy, feedback so softened it never lands. Drop the care and keep only the challenge, and you get Obnoxious Aggression: technically honest, and cruel. Both get mistaken for the safe choice. Neither one is. Honesty and empathy both have to be true at once, or neither one is doing its job. Christopher Myers calls the same idea Compassionate Candor. Different name, same argument, and it keeps resurfacing because it keeps being true.

What Good, Rigorous Honesty Already Looks Like

I don’t have to imagine what the honesty half looks like done well. The CIO I succeeded built a training for his managers around it, using two frameworks from Douglas Stone and Sheila Heen’s Thanks for the Feedback: the three kinds of feedback (Appreciation, Coaching, and Evaluation, each answering a different question, and each one mistaken for the wrong kind when a manager doesn’t name which one they’re giving), and the three triggers that make people reject even accurate feedback (Truth, Relationship, and Identity). It ended on a useful move: replace vague labels with specific, data-backed observations, and tie every hard truth to a funded path forward instead of leaving it hanging as a verdict.

It’s rigorous, and it’s right, and it’s the kind of work most orgs never bother to do (most don’t even get as far as naming the three types of feedback, let alone training managers on them). It also arrived wrapped in a competitive frame: language about squaring up, getting past someone’s defenses, comfort treated as the thing costing the org its performance. That framing puts comfort, and by extension empathy, in the position of opponent, something to get past on the way to the truth. I know the leader behind it believes in care personally as much as challenge directly. But a room full of managers can walk out of a training like that having heard only the challenge, and missed that the care was always supposed to be doing just as much work.

What Empathy Requires

So what is empathy supposed to be doing here? That trigger framework isn’t just old theory. A July 2026 Harvard Business Review feature, drawing on over a decade of research, found the same thing from a different angle: people don’t learn from feedback just because they receive it. They learn when the emotions it triggers keep their attention on the work instead of on protecting themselves. Managing that emotional reaction isn’t a soft skill bolted onto honesty. It’s empathy doing its job.

Empathy in leadership doesn’t mean softening the message until it’s unrecognizable. It means caring enough about the person in front of you to think about how the truth is going to land, and doing the work to deliver it in a way that has a chance of landing well, instead of just saying the true thing and calling your job done.

That work looks different depending on who’s doing it. There’s a double empathy problem worth remembering here: empathy doesn’t fail because one person has less of it, it fails when two different ways of processing and expressing it don’t recognize each other. My own version of empathy doesn’t always look like the version people expect. It shows up as directness, as follow-through, as doing something about the problem instead of performing concern about it. That’s still empathy. It’s just not always legible as empathy to someone expecting the softer version.

What Honesty Requires

Honesty in leadership isn’t just saying true things out loud. It’s being willing to have the conversation you’d rather avoid, on the timeline the person needs it, instead of letting it slide until it’s a bigger problem or someone else’s job to raise. Vagueness to spare someone’s feelings isn’t gentleness. It’s a decision that they can’t handle the truth, made on their behalf, without asking them. Failing to coach, mentor, or manage someone honestly isn’t a soft failure or a personality quirk. It’s a failure of our actual job as leaders. Michael Lopp, who’s written about engineering management for two decades as Rands in Repose, puts the job itself plainly:

“Your job, the work you should value the most, is the growth of your team. Compliments and recognition are one way to highlight exceptional work but saying the hard thing always gets their attention.”

The people who’ve given me feedback worth keeping were specific. They named the thing. They didn’t make me guess at what they meant and hope I filled in the right blank.

That’s what a tenet like Growth depends on. You can’t grow past a gap nobody will name for you.

Where I’ve Gotten This Wrong

I’ve landed on both sides of this line. There have been times my directness showed up as bluntness, because I hadn’t paired it with enough attention to how it would land for the person receiving it, and times I’ve softened something so much in the name of kindness that the point got lost, and the person walked away without what they needed to act on. Neither version was empathy. One was honesty without the empathy attached, and the other was empathy without the honesty attached, and both of them failed the person I was supposedly protecting.

When it’s worked, it’s come down to two things held together, not traded off: expectations and support. That combination has quietly been my whole approach for years, longer than I’ve had clean language like “both things are true” to describe it. Alongside it: human-to-human conversation about what’s working and what isn’t, not a review-cycle formality, and the habit of pointing at what went wrong and turning it into what could be done better next time, instead of just naming the failure and walking away.

It scales past one relationship, too. The same principle is what makes blame-free retros work: the group looks honestly at what broke without spending any of that honesty on blaming a person for it. That only holds inside a culture where getting better is the goal, and where using “feedback” to make yourself look better by making someone else look worse is not tolerated. Take that piece away and honesty stops serving growth. It becomes a weapon, and everyone in the room learns fast that the safest move is to stop giving any.

What It Looks Like Together

So what does doing both, at the same time, look like?

  1. Say the true thing. Not a hint at it. Not a version so hedged it could mean three different things.
  2. With the person’s context in mind. Their timing, their history, what they already know, what they’re already carrying.
  3. With a stake in their success. Feedback given because you want the person to grow lands differently than feedback given to make a record of having said something.
  4. Clearly enough that they don’t have to guess. If someone leaves the conversation unsure what you meant, you didn’t finish the job.

Crux

Empathy and honesty were never supposed to be a trade-off. Both are true at once, and together they’re what growth depends on: expectations honest enough to be useful, support solid enough to make them reachable, and enough room to let the growth happen instead of narrating every step of it. A leader worth following gives you the truth about where the bar is, the support to get there, and the space to do it yourself. That’s not two competing leadership styles you have to pick between, or two ends of one dial. It’s the actual job, and it’s harder than either half alone, which is exactly why so many leaders settle for only doing one, even the ones who believe in both.